Lawyers for Lawyers monitored second hearing in trial of Berrak Çağlar
On 14 June 2022, representatives of Lawyers for Lawyers observed the second hearing in the trial of lawyer Berrak Çağlar who is accused of being a member of an armed terrorist organization, after expressing solidarity with her imprisoned colleague lawyers from Turkey and specifically Ebru Timtik and Aytaç Ünsal, who were on a death fast in 2020.
Berrak Çağlar is a member of the ÇHD (Progressive Lawyers Association). She is accused of being a member of an armed terrorist organization, the Revolutionary People’s Liberation Party/Front (DHKP/C), under articles 53, 58 (9), 63 and 314 (2) of the Turkish Criminal Code and article 5 (1) of Turkey’s Anti-Terrorism Law no. 3713. If found guilty, Berrak Çaglar could be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of 7.5 to 10 years.
Lawyers for Lawyers, Avocats Européens Démocrates (AED) and several local lawyers monitored the first hearing in the trial on the 31st of March 2021. The first hearing focused on the evidence against Berrak Çağlar that was gathered after an investigation was started into her, the interviews and speeches Berrak Çağlar conducted in solidarity with imprisoned lawyers from Turkey and about the situation and latest developments in relation to lawyers Ebru Timtik and Aytaç Ünsal. The lawyers requested to examine the tape recordings of the phone calls that were included in the indictment. Furthermore, the travel ban that was imposed on Berrak Çağlar was lifted during the hearing.
The second hearing of 14 June
The second hearing in the case took place from 12:20 – 12:40 (local time) on 14 June 2022. The hearing was attended by two Lawyers for Lawyers representatives, a representative from the AED and a representative from the Union of Italian Criminal Chambers (UCPI) and various local lawyers.
The hearing coincided with the birthday of the late lawyer Ebru Timtik. As part of her defence statement Berrak Çağlar remembered Ebru Timtik. The chief judge argued that Ebru Timtik had no relevance to Berrak Çağlar’s case and stated that the court room was a place to defend herself and that there was no room for propaganda. Berrak Çağlar responded that she is accused of standing in solidarity with Ebru Timtik and that this is deemed unlawful.
During the hearing Berrak Çağlar was represented by two lawyers. The first lawyer responded to the claim of the chief judge by mentioning International Fair Trial Day (IFTD), that was observed on 14 June, and the Ebru Timtik Award that was established as part of IFTD. The lawyer mentioned that information about IFTD will be added to the written defence. She underlined that the case of Ebru Timik is relevant to the case of Berrak Çağlar because her accusation stands in direct relation with the solidarity she expressed with Ebru Timtik.
The lawyer continued by stating that the Istanbul Public Prosecutor’s Office ruled in April 2021 that Berrak Çağlar was not a member of an armed terrorist organization and that there was no need for further investigation based on a complaint filed by a lawyer. Since this record from the Istanbul Public Prosecutor’s Office was not yet part of the case file, the lawyer argued that the record should be added to the case file, which was accepted by the chief judge.
Since Berrak Çağlar did not get the opportunity to talk about the case of Ebru Timtik during the hearing, the second lawyer representing Berrak Çağlar stated that she should be given the possibility to explain herself so she could explain what she did in defence of Ebru Timtik. The judge rejected this request, stating that Berrak Çağlar was heard extensively during the first hearing and that there was thus no need for additional information during this sharing.
At the end of the hearing the judge underlined that all the additional records and documents will be added to case file and will be individually assessed. Moreover, the chief judge announced that the court received the tape recordings of the phone calls that were included in the indictment from the Prosecutor’s Office just before the second hearing, and that the lawyers will obtain a copy of the tape recordings upon request.
The next hearing will take place on 19 October 2022.
 A lawyer who is known for make complaints to various lawyers and the ÇHD, filed a complaint against Berrak Çağlar to the Istanbul Public Prosecutor’s Office. Such a complaint automatically leads to the Istanbul Public Prosecutor’s Office opening a file against a lawyer.
Meer nieuws uit Türkiye
Kroniek van een aangekondigde dood, maar dan in Turkije
Tahir Elçi, advocaat en deken van de Orde van Advocaten van Diyarbakir in Zuidoost-Turkije, werd op zaterdag 28 november 2015 meteen na een persconferentie op klaarlichte dag door het hoofd geschoten en overleed ter plekke. De vrouw van Tahir ElciLees verder
Lawyers convicted to long prison sentences (again)
Introduction After a hearing of 5 days, the Istanbul 18th Heavy Penal Court in Silivri Court House sentenced 19 lawyers to prison sentences up to 20 years and 6 months in the so-called CHD-1 case. This case started in JanuaryLees verder
Statement: Delegation of 60+ International observers condemns court Judgment in prosecution of 21 Lawyers from ÇHD and HHB
Delegation of 60+ International Trial Observers Condemns Court Judgment in Decade-Long Criminal Prosecution of 21 Lawyers from ÇHD (Progressive Lawyers Association) and HHB (People’s Law Office): Delegation Warns That “The World is Watching” This week, we – more than 60Lees verder
Defending the Rule of law in Türkiye – A PEN Norway and Lawyers for Lawyers event
Last Thursday, Lawyers for Lawyers and PEN Norway hosted an Event on Türkiye’s rule of law and the situation of lawyers in the country. With an enthusiastic audience, the event provided many interesting insights from first hand witnesses. On ThursdayLees verder